25+ Unique Things to Do in NYC: Discover Hidden Gems and Unforgettable Experiences

New York City, often called the Big Apple, is famous for its iconic sights like the Statue of Liberty and the Empire State Building. While these landmarks are must-see attractions, there’s so much more to explore beyond the typical tourist paths. I have spent time in this vibrant city and discovered many unique spots that often go unnoticed, yet are equally captivating and enjoyable.

In this article, I’ll share my favorite underrated activities that showcase a different side of NYC. From quiet moments on the Staten Island Ferry to experiencing distinct neighborhoods and local events, these recommendations are perfect for those looking to immerse themselves in the city’s culture and charm. So, if you’re ready to uncover hidden gems and make the most of your time in the city, read on.

Unique Things to Do in Manhattan

1. Explore the Morgan Library’s Treasures

The Morgan Library & Museum is one of my favorite spots in Manhattan. It was once the private library of J.P. Morgan, a wealthy collector of rare books and manuscripts. Walking through its elegant rooms is like stepping into a fairy tale library, complete with stunning architecture and unique artifacts. I suggest taking a guided tour or using an audio guide, as there are limited signs explaining the fascinating history of the library and its collections.

2. Experience a Sofar Sounds Concert

Sofar Sounds offers a unique concert experience unlike any other. When I bought my ticket, I only received the time and neighborhood details. The exact location is sent to me a day before the event. These concerts are held in cozy venues, such as people’s homes or small office spaces, making them feel personal and intimate. Guests usually bring their own drinks and sit on the floor, so I always pack a blanket for comfort. It’s a refreshing way to enjoy live music in a laid-back atmosphere.

3. Visit the Morris-Jumel Mansion

Discovering the Morris-Jumel Mansion was a highlight of my time in NYC. Tucked away in Washington Heights, this historic home is the oldest in Manhattan, dating back to 1765. It served as George Washington’s headquarters during the Revolutionary War, adding to its rich history. The self-guided tour includes fascinating insights into the building’s past. After exploring, I recommend wandering around Washington Heights, which is charming and full of lovely streets.

4. Explore the Tenement Museum

The Tenement Museum on the Lower East Side gives insight into the lives of immigrants who shaped New York City. The museum is located in a former tenement building and features rooms that are redesigned periodically to mirror different eras throughout the city’s history. Visits here allow me to connect with the real stories of those who lived in Manhattan long before me. It’s a unique place that offers a heartfelt look at the city’s immigrant history.

5. Visit the Met Cloisters

Nestled in Fort Tryon Park, the Met Cloisters is a hidden gem that showcases medieval art in a beautiful setting. It’s a part of the Metropolitan Museum of Art, but it feels worlds apart from the main location. The Cloisters feature not only fascinating art pieces but also three stunning gardens that reflect the designs of medieval horticultural texts. I find the peaceful atmosphere here enchanting, making it a perfect escape from the busy city while still appreciating extraordinary art.

6. Enjoy Tasty Treats at Gansevoort Market

Gansevoort Market is a must-visit for food lovers. It’s a vibrant market in the Meatpacking District that offers a variety of food vendors, each serving unique and delicious dishes. From fresh seafood to gourmet tacos, there’s something to satisfy every craving. I enjoy trying new flavors and sharing different dishes with friends here. The lively atmosphere and great food make it a fun spot for a quick bite or a leisurely meal.

By exploring these unusual places in Manhattan, I uncover the rich tapestry of history, culture, and culinary delights that the city has to offer.

Unique Things to Do in Brooklyn

Visit the Brooklyn Museum

The Brooklyn Museum is a must-see for anyone interested in art. It ranks as the second largest museum in New York City. Inside, you can find a wide variety of exhibits, from ancient Egyptian mummies to classic European oil paintings. There’s truly something for everyone!

One highlight is “The Dinner Party,” a remarkable feminist art installation from the 1970s. This exhibit features a grand banquet setting that honors 39 influential women throughout history. If you’re looking for inspiration and a touch of girl power, this exhibit should be at the top of your list!

Enjoy an Egg Cream at Brooklyn Farmacy

When exploring Brooklyn, make sure to stop by Brooklyn Farmacy and Soda Fountain. This charming soda fountain, which opened in 2010, is located in a restored 1920s pharmacy. The vintage décor and original apothecary items give it a nostalgic vibe that’s hard to find elsewhere.

While you’re there, don’t miss out on the egg cream. This unique drink combines chocolate or vanilla syrup, soda water, and milk, creating a delicious treat. If you’re in the mood for something classic, you can also order a delightful ice cream sundae.

See What’s Blooming at the Brooklyn Botanic Garden

If you’re near Prospect Park, take some time to explore the Brooklyn Botanic Garden. This stunning garden is often overlooked but offers a fantastic experience. The garden features various regional sections that showcase different plants and flowers throughout the year.

One of my favorite spots is the desert pavilion, especially in spring and fall. The Japanese garden is another highlight during the summer, where you can enjoy the beautiful landscapes and peaceful atmosphere. I recommend setting aside at least four hours for your visit, as there’s so much to see!

Stroll Through Green-Wood Cemetery

Green-Wood Cemetery is more than just a resting place; it is a historic site worth visiting. Established in 1838, this cemetery covers 478 acres and was one of the most popular tourist spots in the U.S. during the 1860s. It even played a role in the Revolutionary War, specifically during the Battle of Long Island.

You can find the graves of famous figures like Boss Tweed and Leonard Bernstein here. The scenery is beautiful throughout the year, making it a fitting backdrop for a leisurely walk. I suggest taking a guided tour to fully appreciate the grounds and learn about its rich history.

Discover Little Island

Little Island is a unique public park that floats on the Hudson River. This innovative space features beautiful gardens, performance venues, and stunning views of the city skyline. It’s a fantastic place to relax or catch a live show.

While exploring Little Island, you can wander through the lush green areas, take in the views, or enjoy a picnic. The atmosphere is vibrant, and it offers a refreshing break from the urban hustle.

Visit the New York Transit Museum

For those interested in the history of public transportation, the New York Transit Museum is an excellent stop. Located in a former subway station, it showcases the city’s transit history, with vintage subway cars and informative exhibits.

Walking through this museum gives you a glimpse into the growth of New York City and its transit systems. It’s educational yet engaging, making it a perfect spot for visitors of all ages.

Explore Coney Island

Coney Island is an iconic destination that knows how to blend fun and history. Famous for its boardwalk, amusement park, and beach, it’s a great spot for a day trip. You can indulge in classic boardwalk food like hot dogs or cotton candy while enjoying the lively atmosphere.

Don’t forget to check out the Cyclone, one of the oldest wooden roller coasters in the country. It’s a thrilling ride and a piece of amusement history. Whether you’re looking to relax on the beach or enjoy the rides, Coney Island has something for everyone.

These activities highlight the unique experiences Brooklyn has to offer, showcasing its rich culture and vibrant local atmosphere.

Unique Things to Do in the Bronx

25. Savor Authentic Italian Cuisine on Arthur Avenue

When I think about Italian food in New York City, Arthur Avenue is at the top of my list. This area is often called the true Little Italy of NYC. On Arthur Avenue, you can find a variety of Italian grocery stores, bakeries, and enticing restaurants that serve traditional dishes. Unlike the more touristy spots, it maintains an authentic charm that keeps it from getting overcrowded.

Each visit feels like a treasure hunt, with places offering fresh pasta and delicious pastries. I love stopping by the local butcher shops and chatting with the owners, who are friendly and knowledgeable about their products.

While you’re in this vibrant neighborhood, consider visiting the New York Botanical Garden or the Bronx Zoo to make the most of your day. Not too far from here, Van Cortlandt Park offers beautiful trails perfect for a stroll.

If you have time, head to City Island, where you can enjoy seafood overlooking the water, or explore the history of Woodlawn Cemetery. Both places showcase the Bronx’s unique character. Each one provides a glimpse into the rich tapestry of this borough beyond the typical tourist spots.

Unique Things to Do in Queens

26. Enjoy Affordable Dining in Flushing’s Chinatown

When I think of eateries in New York City, Flushing stands out as a hidden gem that offers some of the best Chinese food around. Located in Queens, this area is often overlooked by tourists, but it is a must-visit for anyone who loves authentic cuisine. The restaurants and bakeries here are plentiful and surprisingly affordable, allowing you to try a variety of dishes without breaking the bank.

After indulging in delicious food, I recommend heading to Flushing Meadows-Corona Park. This park is rich in history, having hosted two World’s Fairs. You can’t miss the iconic Unisphere, a gigantic globe that symbolizes peace and harmony, located right in the heart of the park.

Nearby, the Queens Museum offers an interesting experience with its collection of art and exhibitions. Although it may not be my favorite spot, I know many who appreciate the displays, making it worth a visit, especially with low ticket prices.

Queens is also home to the Louis Armstrong House, where you can explore the life of the famous jazz musician. For those who appreciate art, Socrates Sculpture Park features large-scale sculptures and installations, providing a unique outdoor gallery experience.

If music fascinates you, consider visiting the Steinway Piano Factory to see where these legendary instruments are crafted. Additionally, the Ganesh Temple serves as a cultural anchor, showcasing beautiful architecture and spiritual significance.

Exploring Flushing and these attractions in Queens can lead to memorable experiences that go beyond the usual tourist path.

Unique Things to Do Near NYC

27. Explore the Site of the Historic Duel

A fascinating spot to visit is the location where Alexander Hamilton met his end in a famous duel with Aaron Burr. This historical event took place in Weehawken, New Jersey, on July 11, 1804. While there is no grand monument, a simple plaque marks the site, which is situated on a bluff overlooking the Hudson River. The view of the New York City skyline is stunning from this vantage point.

To reach the dueling grounds, I recommend taking bus routes 165 or 166 from the Port Authority Bus Terminal. Get off at Boulevard East at Bonn Place. The trip is quicker during weekday hours, as traffic near the Lincoln Tunnel can be heavy. If you hit the timing just right, you could make it there in about 15 minutes!

28. Spend a Day at Long Beach

If you’re looking for a relaxing day trip, Long Beach is just a short journey away. This beach destination is perfect for warmer months. With its soft, white sand and a lengthy boardwalk lined with food and drink options, it’s a great place to unwind.

Try to arrive early to secure a good spot on the sand, especially during peak times. The atmosphere is lively, with many families and beachgoers, so getting there ahead of the crowd can make a big difference.

29. Discover Beacon, NY

Just 90 minutes north of New York City lies Beacon, a charming town situated along the Hudson River. The train ride is brief and scenic, offering incredible views of the river as you travel.

In Beacon, I enjoy visiting the unique “castle” on Bannerman Island, which is only reachable by boat—be sure to book a tour in advance. The main street is great for leisurely window shopping, and the Dia Art Museum features impressive contemporary art exhibits. For outdoor enthusiasts, the Hudson Highlands nature trails provide excellent hiking opportunities, particularly beautiful during summer and fall when the foliage is vibrant.

Discover Unique Experiences in NYC!

There are countless hidden experiences waiting for you in New York City, no matter how many times you’ve been here. If you love exploring museums, diving into local culture, visiting historical spots, or just finding a delicious meal, stepping away from the usual tourist attractions reveals a different side of the city. You’ll uncover wonderful surprises that make your visit even more memorable. Embrace the adventure and see what new treasures NYC has to offer!

More Fun Activities to Experience in NYC:

While exploring New York, consider visiting the Museum of Illusions for mind-bending exhibits that engage all ages. Don’t miss the One World Observatory for stunning city views. For sports enthusiasts, a trip to Madison Square Garden offers exciting events and unforgettable memories.